How to Choose an SEO Expert in Pakistan (Written by One)

I get a version of the same message every few weeks: we hired an SEO agency for six months, we got monthly reports, nothing happened. Usually the reports were real. Usually the work was real too. The problem is that neither was connected to the thing the business actually needed.

So here is how I'd evaluate someone in my own field, including me.

Ask what they think is wrong before they've looked

If someone can tell you what your problem is before crawling your site, they are selling a package, not a diagnosis. Every site I've worked on had a different bottleneck. An ecommerce store with 400 near-duplicate category pages needs consolidation. A law firm with three thin location pages needs genuine local relevance. A B2B brand publishing weekly with nothing compounding needs a topic model, not more posts.

The honest answer to "what's wrong with my site?" before an audit is I don't know yet. Anyone comfortable saying that is worth talking to.

Make them show you a site they didn't fix

This is the question almost nobody asks. Every portfolio shows the wins. What you learn from a failure is whether the person understands causation or just correlation.

When I talk about the ecommerce project where organic sessions went up 200%, I also say that revenue didn't move for two months because the checkout was broken. That wasn't an SEO problem. But if I'd stayed quiet about it and claimed the traffic as a revenue win, you'd have learned nothing about how I think.

Check whether they separate rankings from money

Rankings are an input. Traffic is an input. Neither is a result.

A good SEO can tell you which keywords have commercial intent for your business and which are vanity. If someone is proud of ranking you for a term nobody searches before buying, they're optimising for the report.

Ask directly: which of these rankings do you expect to produce enquiries, and which are supporting? If every keyword is equally important, none of them have been thought about.

Ask how they'd handle your developers

Most meaningful SEO work in Pakistan and everywhere else is technical, and most technical work has to be implemented by someone. If the SEO can't write a clear ticket, the recommendation dies in a backlog.

I'd rather work with a client whose developer pushes back on me than one who forwards my document and never reads it. Pushback means someone is thinking.

Pricing: what's actually normal

Rates in Pakistan vary enormously, and cheap is not automatically bad. What matters is what the number buys.

A low monthly retainer that covers "10 blog posts and 20 backlinks" is a content mill. A higher retainer that covers a real crawl, a prioritised fix list, implementation support and measurement is a different service that happens to share a name.

Ask what happens in month one, specifically, hour by hour if they'll tell you. The answer reveals more than the price.

The questions I'd ask me

If you were vetting me, these are the ones I'd find hardest and most useful:

• What would you do first on my site, and why that before anything else?
• What's the most likely reason this doesn't work?
• How long before we know whether it's working — not before it's finished, before we know?
• What do you need from my team that we probably won't want to give you?

The last one matters. Good SEO usually requires something uncomfortable: deleting pages, merging content, slowing down publishing, rebuilding a navigation. If the plan asks nothing of you, it probably changes nothing.

Where Pakistan-based specialists have an actual advantage

There's a real one, and it isn't just cost. Working across US, UK and Gulf markets from Islamabad means seeing the same problems in very different competitive conditions. A tactic that's saturated in US legal search is often untouched in a Gulf market. That pattern recognition is hard to get from inside one market.

The disadvantage is equally real: you cannot understand local search intent in a city you've never worked in without doing the research properly. Anyone who claims otherwise is guessing.

---

If you want a straight answer about your own site, the free audit is the fastest way to get one. I crawl the site myself and tell you the three things costing you the most — including when the answer is that SEO isn't your problem.